“A Generation of Men Without History”: Fight Club, Masculinity, and the Historical Symptom

  Krister Friday English Department Michigan State University kfriday@msu.edu   There is a brief but suggestive moment in Chuck Palahiuk’s popular novel, Fight Club, in which the first-person, unnamed narrator describes how Tyler Durden splices tiny pornographic frames into film reels. In the scene (dramatized in David Fincher’s largely faithful cinematic adaptation of the novel), […]

Barrett Watten’s Bad History: A Counter-Epic of the Gulf War

Philip Metres Department of English John Carroll University pmetres@jcu.edu      More than a decade has passed since the 1991 Persian Gulf War, a war that offered up an “instant history” that effaced the histories of colonialism and empire in the Middle East, thanks to saturation media coverage that covered up far more than it […]

The Body of the Letter: Epistolary Acts of Simon Hantaï, Jean-Luc Nancy, and Jacques Derrida

Julie Hayes Department of Modern Languages and Literatures University of Richmond jhayes@richmond.edu Editor’s Note: For the original French versions of selected quotations, please mouse over or click on the ¤ symbol.       “Lire, écrire, affaire de tact” J-L Nancy   In the summer of 1999, Jean-Luc Nancy wrote to the artist Simon Hantaï […]

Is There a Subject in Hyperreality?

Temenuga Trifonova Film Studies University of California, San Diego ttrifonova@UCSD.Edu   The discourse of materiality or objective reality today is, first of all, a discourse of ethics. Objective reality is either treated as a victim that has been wronged by subjectivity (the latter must, therefore, be brought to justice) or is regarded as “fearful,” “fatal,” […]

The Architecture of Information: Open Source Software and Tactical Poststructuralist Anarchism

Michael Truscello Department of English University of Waterloo novel_t@rogers.com Introduction   The traces of power in the network society are equally located in the architecture of bricks and mortar and the architecture of information, the discursive practices that constitute the coding of network topologies. This paper examines the discourse of computer programming through Eric Raymond’s […]

Notices

      Volume 14, Number 1 September, 2003 Every issue of Postmodern Culturecarries notices of events, calls for papers, and other announcements, free of charge. Advertisements will also be published on an exchange basis. If you respond to one of the ads or announcements below, please mention that you saw the notice in PMC. […]

Theatres of Memory: The Politics and Poetics of Improvised Social Dancing in Queer Clubs

Theresa Smalec Performance Studies New York University tks201@nyu.edu   Review of: Buckland, Fiona. Impossible Dance: Club Culture and Queer World-Making. Middletown, CT: Wesleyan UP, 2002.   Scholars who take up Fiona Buckland’s Impossible Dance: Club Culture and Queer World-Making will step into the vastly underexplored arena that Buckland defines as “improvised social dancing in queer […]

The Speedy Citizen

Valerie Karno English Department University of Rhode Island karno@uri.edu   Review of: Scarry, Elaine. Who Defended the Country? Elaine Scarry in A New Democracy Forum On Citizenship, National Security, and 9/11. Eds. Joshua Cohen and Joel Rogers. Boston: Beacon, 2003.   The collection, “Who Defended the Country,” with title essay by Elaine Scarry and reply […]

Responsible Stupidity

Diane Davis Division of Rhetoric and Department of English University of Texas at Austin ddd@mail.utexas.edu    Review of: Ronell, Avital. Stupidity.Urbana: U of Illinois P, 2001.   It takes a lot of courage to write a book about stupidity. And to call that book simply Stupidity, not even bothering to frame the term in a […]

Materiality is the Message

Del Doughty Department of English Huntington College ddoughty@huntington.edu   Review of: N. Katherine Hayles, Writing Machines.Mediawork Pamphlet. Cambridge: MIT P, 2002.   The first thing I noticed about N. Katherine Hayles’s Writing Machines was its design: its slimness (138 pages) and its texture. The pages are printed on the heavy, glossy paper typical of fashion […]

Gullivers, Lilliputians, and the Root of Two Cultures

Claudia Brodsky Lacour Department of Comparative Literature Princeton University cblacour@princeton.edu   Review of: Arkady Plotnitsky, The Knowable and the Unknowable: Modern Science, Nonclassical Thought, and the “Two Cultures.”Ann Arbor: U of Michigan P, 2002.   In The Knowable and the Unknowable, Arkady Plotnitsky takes on (at least) two unenviable double tasks. He endeavors to explain […]

A Response to Leonard Wilcox’s “Baudrillard, September 11, and the Haunting Abyss of Reversal”

Brad Butterfield Department of English University of Wisconsin, La Crosse butterfi.brad@uwlax.edu   Leonard Wilcox is right that the conception of symbolic exchange has continued to inform Baudrillard’s work up to the present, but until 9/11 Baudrillard had stopped using the language of symbolic exchange, preferring instead to speak in terms of “seduction,” “fatal strategies,” and […]

Baudrillard, September 11, and the Haunting Abyss of Reversal

Leonard Wilcox Department of American Studies University of Canterbury Leonard.Wilcox@canterbury.ac.nz   . . . at the height of their coherence, the redoubled signs of the code are haunted by the abyss of reversal. –Jean Baudrillard, Symbolic Exchange and Death   In his article “The Baudrillardian Symbolic, 9/11, and the War of Good and Evil,” Bradley […]

Smart Bombs, Serial Killing, and the Rapture: The Vanishing Bodies of Imperial Apocalypticism

Peter Yoonsuk Paik Department of French, Italian, and Comparative Literature University of Wisconsin at Milwaukee pypaik@uwm.edu   One of the most well-publicized hypotheses regarding the terror of 9/11 is the notion that religious fantasies played a major role in inspiring the militants of al-Qaeda to launch their suicide attacks on the World Trade Center and […]

Constellation and Critique: Adorno’s Constellation, Benjamin’s Dialectical Image

Steven Helmling Department of English University of Delaware helmling@udel.edu   Fredric Jameson years ago characterized Adorno’s chief critical device or method as the “historical trope” (Marxism and Form 3-59), so it shouldn’t strike anyone as a novel claim that Adorno’s “constellation” displays affinities with other now-familiar devices of modernist art and literature–Eisensteinian montage, cubist collage, […]

Postmodern Historiography: Politics and the Parallactic Method in Thomas Pynchon’s Mason & Dixon

Christy L. Burns Department of English College of William and Mary clburn@wm.edu   In 1997, Thomas Pynchon published Mason & Dixon, his much anticipated history of America written from the perspectives of the astronomer and surveyor sent over from England to draw the famous boundary line. Their work was necessitated by a long-standing dispute between […]

Exiles on Main Stream: Valuing the Popularity of Postcolonial Literature

Chris Bongie Department of English Queen’s University bongiec@qsilver.queensu.ca   Put me in a room with a great writer, I grovel. Put me in with Roseanne, I throw up. –Jamaica Kincaid1   When Tina Brown asked Roseanne Barr to serve as guest consultant for a special women’s issue of The New Yorker in 1995, Antiguan-American novelist […]

Notices

      Volume 14, Number 2 January, 2004 Every issue of Postmodern Culturecarries notices of events, calls for papers, and other announcements, free of charge. Advertisements will also be published on an exchange basis. If you respond to one of the ads or announcements below, please mention that you saw the notice in PMC. […]

Exposition in Ruins

Charles Sheaffer Department of Cultural Studies and Comparative Literature University of Minnesota Shea0016@umn.edu   Review of: Gregory Ulmer, Internet Invention. New York: Pearson, 2003.   Gregory Ulmer’s Internet Invention can be accurately described as a composition handbook for students working in an increasingly visual culture–provided that one follows Ulmer in understanding the newfound prevalence of […]

Killing the Big Other

Daniel Worden Department of English & American Literature Brandeis University dworden@brandeis.edu   Review of: Slavoj Zizek, The Puppet and the Dwarf: The Perverse Core of Christianity.Cambridge: MIT P, 2003.   The first book in his “Short Circuits” series from MIT Press, Slavoj Zizek’s The Puppet and the Dwarf: The Perverse Core of Christianity strives to […]

Irigaray’s Erotic Ontology

Hillary L. Chute Department of English Rutgers University Kinny8@hotmail.com   Review of: Luce Irigaray, Between East and West: From Singularity to Community.New York: Columbia UP, 2002.   Many contemporary feminist thinkers reject the accusation, most forcefully leveled by Monique Plaza in 1978, that Luce Irigaray’s theories of the feminine are naturalist. Irigaray’s conception of “the […]

Not Just a Matter of the Internet

Stuart J. Murray Department of Rhetoric University of California, Berkeley sjmurray@socrates.berkeley.edu   Review of: Mark Poster, What’s the Matter with the Internet?.Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 2001.   There is surely a double entendre at work in the title of Mark Poster’s book, What’s the Matter with the Internet?. In this matter, it is not […]

Pain-in-the-ass Democracy

Jeffrey T. Nealon Department of English Pennsylvania State University jxn8@psu.edu   Review of: John McGowan, Democracy’s Children: Intellectuals and the Rise of Cultural Politics.Ithaca, NY: Cornell UP, 2002.   Are we so confident in our current formulations that we would not value the person who comes along to challenge them? More likely than not, that […]

Evolution and Contingency

Arkady Plotnitsky Theory and Cultural Studies Program Purdue University aplotnit@sla.purdue.edu   Review of: Gould, Stephen J. The Structure of Evolutionary Theory.Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP, 2002.   We often complain about long books, and, at nearly 1500 pages, Stephen Jay Gould’s magnum opus is about as long as one could find in the sciences. But then, […]

Montage/Critique: Another Way of Writing Social History

George Dillon Department of English University of Washington dillon@u.washington.edu   In the last 40 years, numbers of writers and artists have come to see Walter Benjamin as a pioneer who blazed a new way of writing historical and cultural critique. The drafts of and reflections upon his Arcades Project (Passagen-Werk) have been the subject of […]

“Eden or Ebb of the Sea”: Susan Howe’s Word Squares and Postlinear Poetics

Brian Reed Department of English University of Washington, Seattle bmreed@u.washington.edu   In Poetry On & Off the Page(1998), Marjorie Perloff argues that the era of free verse may be drawing to a close. She examines recent work by a number of avant-garde poets–among them Caroline Bergvall, Karen Mac Cormack, Susan Howe, Maggie O’Sullivan, Joan Retallack, […]

Reading Game/Text: EverQuest, Alienation, and Digital Communities

Eric Hayot Department of English University of Arizona ehayot@u.arizona.edu   Edward Wesp Department of English University of Wisconsin at Milwaukee edwesp@uwm.edu   A lot had to happen between 1915, when the U.S. Supreme Court first ruled that cinema was not “speech” and was thus unprotected by the First Amendment, and 1982, when the Court decided […]

From Advertising to the Avant-Garde: Rethinking the Invention of Collage

David Banash Department of English Western Illinois University D-Banash@wiu.edu   I see no reason why the artistic world can’t absolutely merge with Madison Avenue   –William S. Burroughs (“Art of Fiction” 29)   Cutting Up Consumer Culture: “Big Daddy”   In her article “The Invention of Collage,” Marjorie Perloff begins the story of collage at […]

Notices

      Volume 14, Number 3 May, 2004 Every issue of Postmodern Culturecarries notices of events, calls for papers, and other announcements, free of charge. Advertisements will also be published on an exchange basis. If you respond to one of the ads or announcements below, please mention that you saw the notice in PMC. […]

Spectres of Freedom in Stirner and Foucault: A Response to Caleb Smith’s “Solitude and Freedom”

Saul Newman Department of Political Science University of Western Australia snewman@cyllene.uwa.edu.au   I am grateful to Caleb Smith for his response to my essay “Stirner and Foucault: Towards a Post-Kantian Freedom,” and I particularly like the way he links my discussion of a post-Kantian freedom to strategies of resistance against contemporary forms of incarceration. Already, […]

Solitude and Freedom: A Response to Saul Newman on Stirner and Foucault

Caleb Smith Department of English Duke University cjs5@duke.edu   In a recent essay on “Stirner and Foucault,” Saul Newman brings these “two thinkers not often examined together” into a conversation about freedom, coercion, and individual subjectivity. Newman uses Stirner and Foucault to explore a discourse of freedom formulated by Kant and dominant since the Enlightenment, […]

Excursions into Everyday Life

David Alvarez Department of English Grand Valley State University alvarezd@gvsu.edu   Review of: Ben Highmore, ed., The Everyday Life Reader.London: Routledge, 2002.   Perhaps it is one of the symptoms of our theory-saturated, post-everything moment that everyday life has recently become not just an object of cultural analysis, but a crucial interpretive category in its […]

Supporting the Cage

Andy Weaver Department of English University of Alberta aweaver@ualberta.ca   Review of: David W. Bernstein and Christopher Hatch, eds., Writings through John Cage’s Music, Poetry, and Art.Chicago: U of Chicago P, 2001.   Agree or disagree with his aesthetics, his ideas, or his politics, no one seriously engaged in studying the arts of the twentieth […]

Aesthetic Primacy, Cultural Identity, and Human Agency

Michael S. Martin English Department Temple University msmartin@temple.edu   Review of: Emory Elliott, Louis Fretas Caton, and Jeffrey Rhyne, eds., Aesthetics in a Multicultural Age.New York and Oxford: Oxford UP, 2002.   “Let us, for example, credit it to the honor of Kant that he should expatiate on the peculiar properties of the sense of […]

Poet, Actor, Spectator

Stuart Kendall stuartkendall@kanandesign.com   Review of: Clayton Eshleman, Juniper Fuse: Upper Paleolithic Imagination and the Construction of the Underworld.Middleton, CT: Wesleyan UP, 2003.   Section five of Nietzsche’s The Birth of Tragedy ends with a curious figure, a “weird image from a fairy tale which can turn its eyes at will and behold itself […] […]

Lyotard’s Anti-Aesthetics: Voice and Immateriality in Postmodern Art

Gillian B. Pierce Department of Foreign Languages Ashland University gpierce@ashland.edu   Review of: Jean-François Lyotard, Soundproof Room: Malraux’s Anti-Aesthetics. Trans. David Harvey. Stanford, CA: Stanford UP, 2001. (Originally published in French under the title Chambre Sourde: L’Antiesthétique de Malraux.Paris: Editions Galilée, 1998.)   Soundproof Room, the final completed work by the cultural philosopher Jean-François Lyotard, […]

Virtually: The Refreshment of Interface Value

Robert Payne School of Humanities University of Western Sydney r.j.payne@uws.edu.au   In April 2002, the Supreme Court of the United States handed down its ruling of Ashcroft v. Free Speech Coalition, a case in which a certain semantic specificity seemed ultimately to take precedence over the moral and emotional imperatives that propelled the central argument […]

“Myriad Little Connections”: Minoritarian Movements in the Postmodernism Debate

  Pelagia Goulimari Angelaki: Journal of the Theoretical Humanities goulimari@angelaki1.demon.co.uk   The vast postmodernism debate, whose expansive and canonical phase spanned from the early 1980s to the mid-1990s but which has yet to reach a point of settlement or closure, engages with a multiplicity of questions, among which “what is postmodernism?” is not necessarily the […]

The Time of Interpretation: Psychoanalysis and the Past

Jason B. Jones Department of English Central Connecticut State University jonesjason1@ccsu.edu   In his seminar of 1966-67 on the logic of fantasy, Jacques Lacan reported to his audience that he had recently been asked what need, what exigency drove him to theorize the objet a as object/cause of desire. According to the transcripts of this […]

The Human and his Spectacular Autumn, or, Informatics after Philosophy

Anustup Basu Department of English University of Pittsburgh anbst42@pitt.edu   Toward the beginning of Gabriel García Márquez’s novel El Otono del Patriarca, the protagonist, who is the dictator of an imaginary Latin American republic, is seen to witness his own funeral. That is, he sees himself being buried de facto, in terms of an ordering […]